Tuesday, July 8, 2025
77.2 F
Roseville

The Fire Fee Shell Game: You Lose!

Democrats in the California Legislature seem to be facing the reality that the fire tax they passed with the Governor’s help in 2011 is unfair.

Californians who live in rural areas rely on a range of public services from multiple levels of government to combat fires. These residents already pay taxes to fund essential fire services.

The original fire fee was a scheme Governor Brown came up with after diverting about $90 million a year in fire prevention funds to help “balance” the state budget. Residents have gained nothing since this shell game passed. Not a dime of fire fee revenues can be used for actual fire suppression – trucks, planes or hoses. The funds can only be used for “prevention” efforts, which seem to be few and far between.
However, instead of simply repealing this onerous fire prevention fee, Democrats now want to replace a really bad policy with an even worse one.

AB 1203, authored by Assemblyman Reggie Jones-Sawyer is currently awaiting consideration by the Legislature. The bill would repeal the fire fee, but replace it with a 3 to 5 percent insurance surcharge on all commercial and residential property statewide. The money collected from this fee would then be used to create a disaster response fund in the State Treasury.

Right now, this proposal is nothing more than a massive tax increase designed to further fund government bureaucracy. The current fire tax brings in about $80 million a year in revenue to the state coffers.  If AB 1203 were to pass, that number could skyrocket to $500 million or more a year. That’s a colossal difference.

At a time when California is collecting record revenues, does Sacramento really need more of your money? For the month of March alone, revenues have come in $547 million higher than anticipated by the Governor’s budget.

Based on a $1,000 premium, a small business owner could end up paying tens of thousands of dollars more for insurance. And if you’re a residential property owner, you’d get hit with an insurance surcharge as well. 

Why should Californians have to purchase additional insurance for something their tax dollars should already guarantee? Imagine having to purchase a crime insurance policy to ensure that local and state police respond to your 911 calls-that wouldn’t be effective or fair public policy, and neither is AB 1203.

Protecting Californians shouldn’t require new taxes or fees; public safety should be first, not last, in line for spending existing public dollars. If the state’s emergency readiness lacks adequate funding, California needs to do a better job prioritizing the more than $100 billion in taxes that taxpayers are currently sending to Sacramento each year.

Jones-Sawyer’s legislation requires a two-thirds vote.  I hope both Democrats and Republicans will oppose this new tax proposal. It’s hard to imagine why the Legislature would replace a bad policy with an even worse one. Sadly, though, stranger things have happened in Sacramento.

The Legislature should repeal California’s illegal fire tax not replace it with a massive insurance scheme that will make life even more costly for Californians.

George Runner represents more than nine million Californians as a taxpayer advocate and elected member of the State Board of Equalization.

Mendocino 2025

Fleming's Roseville

New Summer Menu!

🍎 Gravenstein Apple Fair

Trending

Range Rover a powerful Plug-in Hybrid SUV

Roseville, Calif.- It doesn't take long to discover the 2025 Range Rover plug-in hybrid is a highly sophisticated SUV that typifies a luxury brand.

Jaguar Rocklin

Visit Jaguar Rocklin, to shop from a wide selection of Jaguar luxury sedans, sports cars, and SUVs. We also offer Jaguar financing, parts & service.

See’s Candies on Douglas Blvd in Roseville

See's Candies chocolate shop at 1825 Douglas Blvd in Roseville is Now Open for online orders & pick up.

7′ Yen Sushi in Roseville

7 Yen Sushi brings an artfully crafted Japanese cuisine to Roseville, California. Their menu caters to a variety of sushi, ramen, and vegan options.

Hidden Epidemic: Clinical depression and its far-reaching causes

Sacramento, Calif. - Depression significantly impacts the lives of at least 10% of the U.S. population. If the same percentage applies to Davis, approximately 6,600 residents in our town suffer from clinical depression.

Topics

Range Rover a powerful Plug-in Hybrid SUV

Roseville, Calif.- It doesn't take long to discover the 2025 Range Rover plug-in hybrid is a highly sophisticated SUV that typifies a luxury brand.

Jaguar Rocklin

Visit Jaguar Rocklin, to shop from a wide selection of Jaguar luxury sedans, sports cars, and SUVs. We also offer Jaguar financing, parts & service.

See’s Candies on Douglas Blvd in Roseville

See's Candies chocolate shop at 1825 Douglas Blvd in Roseville is Now Open for online orders & pick up.

7′ Yen Sushi in Roseville

7 Yen Sushi brings an artfully crafted Japanese cuisine to Roseville, California. Their menu caters to a variety of sushi, ramen, and vegan options.

Hidden Epidemic: Clinical depression and its far-reaching causes

Sacramento, Calif. - Depression significantly impacts the lives of at least 10% of the U.S. population. If the same percentage applies to Davis, approximately 6,600 residents in our town suffer from clinical depression.

Rose Cafe’ & Bagel in Roseville

Rose Cafe' & Bagel in west Roseville bagel and coffee shop.

Winsted Apartments in Rocklin

Winsted at Sunset West offers 1, 2 & 3 bedroom apartments in Rocklin, CA! Fantastic amenities + Great location near Fountains at Roseville.

Round Pizza and Wings

Round Pizza & Wings serves a variety of pizzas and an over-the-top experience from the moment you walk in. Located in Roseville, CA.

Related Articles

Local Spotlight

California Fence and Patio serving Placer County for over 30 years

Loomis, Calif. - California Fence & Patio is proud of their reputation as the premier fencing and patio cover contractor in the Roseville,, Sacramento and Placer County region.

Mobley Pest Services in Roseville serving the community and region for over 20 years

Roseville, Calif.- Fully licensed and bonded, Mobley Pest Services in Roseville has been providing reliable pest control services for well over 20 years. Serving residents and businesses in the greater Placer and Sacramento region, Mobley Pest Services is locally owned and operated in Roseville.

Roseville Sheet Metal serving community’s heating and air needs for over 70 years

Roseville, Calif. - At Roseville Sheet Metal, we’re proud of our years of service to the Roseville area and look forward to helping you with your air conditioning and heating needs.