Common Autism Screening Tool is effective, but has limitations says study

According to new UC Davis MIND Institute study

Sacramento, Calif.- A new study by UC Davis MIND Institute researchers and others finds that an autism screening tool used widely in the U.S. and around the world is effective but has limitations. The findings highlight the need for providers to use their own judgment and be clear with parents about the limits of the tool, called the M-CHAT-R/F (Modified Checklist for Autism in Toddlers, Revised with Follow-Up).

The researchers analyzed more than a dozen studies of the screening tool from around the world, which included tens of thousands of children. Their work was recently published American Academy of Pediatrics.

The M-CHAT-R/F is a tool commonly used by pediatricians to screen children for autism around the world. It includes a set of questions that providers ask parents or caregivers about their child's development, and usually takes about five minutes to administer. If the child receives a positive screening result, a provider usually recommends further evaluation.

False flags

The team found that the tool commonly flagged children as positive for autistic traits, who, after a full assessment, did not receive an autism diagnosis, though most did have other developmental challenges. In addition, a significant portion of children who were flagged as negative for autistic traits were later diagnosed with autism.

"Although the M-CHAT-R/F has a clear role in autism screening, these results remind clinicians that a positive screen is not equivalent to an autism diagnosis," said lead author Aishworiya Ramkumar, assistant professor in the Department of Pediatrics at the National University of Singapore. Ramkumar is also a former ITPND (International Training Program in Neurodevelopmental Disabilities) fellow at the MIND Institute.

"When clinicians counsel parents and caregivers after a positive screening they must be clear that the child still needs to have a definitive assessment."

Autism is a developmental disability which includes brain differences. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 1 in 36 U.S. children has autism. Autistic individuals may communicate, learn and behave differently, and their abilities can vary widely. In the U.S., the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends autism screening at both 18 and 24 months of age.

"Screening tools help to identify children who are most likely to have developmental concerns. These children can then receive diagnostic evaluations and, if appropriate, can get the educational, therapeutic and social support they need to maximize their potential," said Van Ma, a developmental-behavioral pediatrics fellow at the MIND Institute and a co-author of the paper.

Study design and results

The meta-analysis included 13 studies, covering a total of 49,841 children from 10 countries. Studies took place between January 2014 and November 2021 and included standard scoring of the M-CHAT-R/F and a diagnostic assessment for autism following the screening result.
Among all children, the pooled predictive value, or accuracy of the M-CHAT-R/F at correctly identifying autism, was 57.7%. This means that there was a 57.7% chance of an autism diagnosis following a "positive" screen. The number varied when children were sorted into groups. For example, in children who had a higher likelihood of autism, such as those with an autistic sibling, the predictive value was 75.6%. Among children with no increased likelihood, the predictive value was 51.2%.

The overall negative predictive value was 72.5%. This means that nearly a quarter of those flagged as "negative" following screening received an autism diagnosis after further assessment.

Ramkumar emphasizes that providers should not view the screening tool as definitive.

"Clinical assessment is important, regardless of the M-CHAT-R/F results. It's also critical to remember that not all children with autism have features in early childhood and instead, they may become apparent only later. A negative screening at a single point in time does not necessarily rule out autism," she said.

M-CHAT-R/F

The M-CHAT-R/F is the most common autism screening tool, but most previous studies have focused on or included earlier versions of it in their analysis.

Early diagnosis

"Early diagnosis of autism is critical for improved outcomes, so we thought it was very important to review the utility of this widely used tool in screening for autism in young children," Ramkumar explained. "We realized the value of compiling a large sample size to guide clinicians regarding use of the M-CHAT-R/F."

Ramkumar notes that they only included studies where children who screened as negative for autism also received a full diagnostic evaluation, rather than just assuming that they did not have the condition. However, most studies had small numbers of children who fit this profile.

What do the findings mean for health care providers?

The M-CHAT-R/F is a tool that is frequently used in pediatric offices at the 18- and 24-month well child visits," said senior author on the paper Heidi Feldman, professor and chief of the Division of Developmental-Behavioral Pediatrics at Stanford University. "It is so important for clinicians to think carefully about the results of the screening test, to neither unnecessarily concern parents nor to inaccurately reassure parents."

The authors all emphasize that individual provider judgment is key.

"I think the most important takeaway from this study is that the M-CHAT-R/F is a screening tool with limitations," Ma explained. It has a role in screening for autism but is not meant to replace clinical judgment and comprehensive diagnostic assessment."

Other study authors included Susan Stewart and Randi Hagerman of UC Davis.

Funding was provided by the National Institutes of Health (UL1 TR001860, P50HD103526) and the Health Resources and Services Administration (T77MC25733, T77MC09796).

related


Become a Sustaining Patron

100% voluntary • Cancel anytime • No paywall

Roseville Today remains free for everyone.
Your voluntary monthly support helps us continue serving the community.

Folsom Ice Skating Rink

Local Insights

Trending

November 2026 at California's 10 largest reservoirs

Folsom, Calif.- Status updates for major California reservoirs as rain season gets underway. Planning is in full swing as the potential Super El-Nino is forecasted to bring much heavier rains across California this upcoming wet season.

Folsom Ice Skating Rink Now Open for 2026 Holiday Season

Folsom, Calif. - The 2026 Ice Skating Season in the Historic District of Folsom gets underway November 7, 2026! It's time to skate into the season of fun! We've been working hard to bring some positive changes to the rink…we think you're going to love our updated ice skating scene!

Stop Identity Thieves in Their Tracks: Freeze Your Credit

A credit freeze is a free and effective way to help protect yourself from identity theft. Learn how to freeze your credit with Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion, when to use a fraud alert, and how to protect your personal financial information

Hope Valley: California's Autumn Wonderland

Alpine County, Calif. - Draped in hues of golden yellow and pumpkin orange, groves of aspen trees shimmer with the arrival of fall. This is Hope Valley, California — a fall foliage wonderland where October

New Alchemy Surf Resort Coming to Edge of Roseville, Rocklin, & Lincoln

Roseville, Calif.- The Placer County Planning Commission has approved plans for the Alchemy Surf Resort, a new recreational surf and hospitality destination planned within the Placer One development.

Roseville Salmon Homecoming 2026 Celebrates Return of Chinook Salmon at Royer Park

Roseville will host its first-ever Salmon Homecoming on November 8 at Royer Park. The free family-friendly event celebrates the annual return of Chinook salmon to Dry Creek and features a new 11-by-26-foot salmon mural, guided creek walks and opportunities to learn about local wildlife conservation.

Placer Breast Cancer Foundation Supports Roseville Cancer Patients

The Placer Breast Cancer Foundation is funding expanded cancer rehabilitation, lymphedema services, wigs and head coverings to support breast cancer patients at Sutter Roseville and Kaiser Permanente Roseville.

Placer SPCA: Halloween Tips to Protect your Pets

Roseville, CA - Pet owners' goals should be to take all of the necessary steps to minimize these potential hazards, keep your pet secure at home, and ensure a safe and fun Halloween for all."

Roseville Halloween safety tips for drivers and trick-or-treaters

Roseville, Calif.- Autumn leaves have begun changing colors and the crisp, cool mornings have arrived in Roseville. Halloween and the holiday season is upon us.

Halloween safety tips from the Roseville Police Department

Roseville, Calif.-  It's the time of year for fall festivals, trunk-or-treats, and Halloween parties. We should all recognize the fact that most of the year we should tell our kids not to take candy from strangers.

Related Articles

Sponsored Local Spotlight

Steve Wallen Swim School in Roseville Has Taught Safe Swimming Skills for Over 40 Years

Roseville, Calif. - Steve Wallen Swim School in Roseville teaches swim lessons and water safety for infants, kids, and adults of all skill levels.

Mobley Pest Services in Roseville serving the community and region for over 20 years

Roseville, Calif.- Fully licensed and bonded, Mobley Pest Services in Roseville has been providing reliable pest control services for well over 20 years. Serving residents and businesses in the greater Placer and Sacramento region, Mobley Pest Services is locally owned and operated in Roseville.

Paul Black's Solar Panel Cleaning in Roseville serving the region for over 30 years

Roseville, Calif. - Money-saving solar panels in Roseville, Rocklin and throughout South Placer County have become ubiquitous From new residential solar communities continue to big business and after market installation, solar seems to be a smart choice to shred those high monthly electric costs.