In Cancer, Talking About Bad News Can Be Good

Possible benefits in terms of future quality of life

Sacramento, Calif. – Giving bad news is never easy, especially when it's life or death. But when an oncologist delivers a poor prognosis to a cancer patient, does it harm their relationship?  Some research studies have suggested it can.

A new study by UC Davis and University of Rochester researchers demonstrates that it does not. In fact, it found that the patient-doctor alliance can be strengthened after a discussion about prognosis.

Appearing  today in the Journal of Clinical Oncology, the study may provide reassurance to oncologists worried that talking about a patient's chances of survival may do more harm than good.

"We hope this information will reassure clinicians about any negative impacts of these discussions on their relationships with patients," said lead author Joshua Fenton, a professor of family and community medicine at UC Davis. "Discussing prognosis doesn't undermine trust, and informing patients may have large benefits in terms of future quality of life."

Fenton explains that while patients with illnesses that may limit their lives rely on their physicians to talk with them about their disease and prognosis, many oncologists instead emphasize treatment options, spending little time discussing prognosis or end-of-life options such as palliative care and hospice. The result can be greater use of intensive, hospital-based services, higher health care costs, lower quality of life for patients, more difficulties for caregivers and even shortened survival.

"Prognosis discussions don't happen early and often, and, as a result, it's been clearly documented that many patients often completely misunderstand their prognosis so treatment decisions made near the end of life might not be totally aligned with the patients' and caregivers' priorities," he said.

The study is an outgrowth of earlier research which found that patients with stage III or IV cancer reported far more optimistic expectations for survival than their oncologists thought they had communicated, which has implications for the kinds of decisions made near the end of life.

For the new study, the researchers recruited 238 adult patients with advanced cancer visiting 38 oncologists within community and hospital-based cancer clinics in Western New York and Northern California, including at the UC Davis Comprehensive Cancer Center.

Patient visits with oncologists were audiotaped and the tapes then analyzed for prognosis discussions. Patients were surveyed 2-7 days after their visit and again at three months to evaluate any changes in the doctor-patient relationship. An analysis of the findings showed that having had a prognosis discussion did not negatively affect the doctor-patient relationship within one week of the conversation and that it actually improved the relationship three months later.

The study contradicts two, more limited studies which found that these discussions can increase a patient's depressive symptoms and disrupt the doctor-patient relationship.

Fenton said that in addition to educating oncologists about the importance of prognosis discussions, he hopes that medical educators enhance their curriculum to train future oncologists in these communications strategies.

"Giving patients bad news is a very small part of our training as clinicians," he said.

Other authors on the study include Richard Kravitz, Guibo Xing and Daniel Tancredi at UC Davis; and Paul Duberstein, Kevin Fiscella, Supriya Mohile and Ronald Epstein at the University of Rochester.

The research was supported by grants from the National Cancer Institute (RO1 CA140419-05 and RO1 CA168387).*UC Davis


Become a Sustaining Patron

100% voluntary • Cancel anytime • No paywall

Roseville Today remains free for everyone.
Your voluntary monthly support helps us continue serving the community.

Succulents for Soups

Local Insights

Trending

Succulents for Soups Returns to Roseville to Fight Food Insecurity

Roseville's annual Succulents for Soups food drive returns November 12 through December 19. Donate nonperishable food to help local families and receive a complimentary succulent while supplies last.

🦃Sold Out! Roseville Turkey Trot Returns Thanksgiving Day 2026

The Roseville Turkey Trot returns to Downtown Roseville on Thanksgiving Day, November 26, 2026. Find 5K and 10K race times, registration prices, packet pickup details and more.

November 2026 at California's 10 largest reservoirs

Folsom, Calif.- Status updates for major California reservoirs as rain season gets underway. Planning is in full swing as the potential Super El-Nino is forecasted to bring much heavier rains across California this upcoming wet season.

Folsom Ice Skating Rink Now Open for 2026 Holiday Season

Folsom, Calif. - The 2026 Ice Skating Season in the Historic District of Folsom gets underway November 7, 2026! It's time to skate into the season of fun! We've been working hard to bring some positive changes to the rink…we think you're going to love our updated ice skating scene!

Stop Identity Thieves in Their Tracks: Freeze Your Credit

A credit freeze is a free and effective way to help protect yourself from identity theft. Learn how to freeze your credit with Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion, when to use a fraud alert, and how to protect your personal financial information

Hope Valley: California's Autumn Wonderland

Alpine County, Calif. - Draped in hues of golden yellow and pumpkin orange, groves of aspen trees shimmer with the arrival of fall. This is Hope Valley, California — a fall foliage wonderland where October

New Alchemy Surf Resort Coming to Edge of Roseville, Rocklin, & Lincoln

Roseville, Calif.- The Placer County Planning Commission has approved plans for the Alchemy Surf Resort, a new recreational surf and hospitality destination planned within the Placer One development.

Roseville Salmon Homecoming 2026 Celebrates Return of Chinook Salmon at Royer Park

Roseville will host its first-ever Salmon Homecoming on November 8 at Royer Park. The free family-friendly event celebrates the annual return of Chinook salmon to Dry Creek and features a new 11-by-26-foot salmon mural, guided creek walks and opportunities to learn about local wildlife conservation.

Placer Breast Cancer Foundation Supports Roseville Cancer Patients

The Placer Breast Cancer Foundation is funding expanded cancer rehabilitation, lymphedema services, wigs and head coverings to support breast cancer patients at Sutter Roseville and Kaiser Permanente Roseville.

Placer SPCA: Halloween Tips to Protect your Pets

Roseville, CA - Pet owners' goals should be to take all of the necessary steps to minimize these potential hazards, keep your pet secure at home, and ensure a safe and fun Halloween for all."

Related Articles

Sponsored Local Spotlight

Roseville Sheet Metal serving community's heating and air needs for over 70 years

Roseville, Calif. - At Roseville Sheet Metal, we’re proud of our years of service to the Roseville area and look forward to helping you with your air conditioning and heating needs.

Stanford Ranch Family Dentistry in Rocklin serving the local community since 2000

Rocklin, Calif.- For nearly 25 years, Jason and Heather have grown their successful Stanford Ranch Family Dentistry practice by faithfully serving patients throughout the Rocklin, Roseville, and greater South Placer County region. Their business has grown to now employ over a dozen employees which helps them meet the growing demands of a successful local business.

Mobley Pest Services in Roseville serving the community and region for over 20 years

Roseville, Calif.- Fully licensed and bonded, Mobley Pest Services in Roseville has been providing reliable pest control services for well over 20 years. Serving residents and businesses in the greater Placer and Sacramento region, Mobley Pest Services is locally owned and operated in Roseville.